I’d start with CALPALMY’s 14 blank masks if you’re making costumes with a group, since one kit supplies two mask sizes for several people. For a single dramatic accent, the Dxhycc marabou boa adds a soft feather trim, while Jashem’s acrylic eyeballs suit masks and props that call for a more lifelike detail. These picks solve different problems: some provide a base to customize, some add decoration quickly, and some are small specialty pieces. I rank them by how directly they help with Halloween costume making, how many projects they can support, and how much extra work or attachment planning they require.
Get art and craft supplies delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Key Takeaways
- CALPALMY’s 14-mask set is the most useful starting point for group costume sessions because it includes seven masks in each of two sizes.
- Dxhycc’s white feather boa is the simplest way here to add a flowing costume accent, though it may need fluffing and can shed.
- Jashem’s 16 acrylic eyeballs offer varied colors and a concave back for glue or stitching, making them better suited to props than quick wearable decoration.
- The 5.9-inch googly eyes make a bold, playful focal point, but the pair count and smooth-surface adhesive limit where they work.
- Choose by construction method: start with a blank mask for a full face design, use feathers for trim, and select eyes only when their scale and attachment method suit the costume.
| CALPALMY 14-Pack Paper Mache Masks, 2 Sizes |  | Best Overall for Group Costume Making | Quantity: 14 masks | Size mix: 7 small and 7 large | Small dimensions: 6.8 × 8 inches | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Dxhycc White Marabou Feather Boa, 2 Yards, 20 g |  | Best for Soft, Flowing Costume Trim | Material: Natural turkey feathers | Color: White | Length: 2 m (6.56 ft) | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Jashem 8 Pairs of 22mm Realistic Acrylic Eyeballs (Blue, Gray, Green, Brown) |  | Best for Realistic Masks and Props | Quantity: 16 pieces (8 pairs) | Specified size: 22 mm (0.87 inch); title also mentions 20 mm | Colors: Blue, gray, green, and brown | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Large Self-Adhesive Googly Eyes, 5.9 Inches, 2-Pack |  | Best for Oversized Playful Costumes | Pack quantity: 2 eyes | Diameter: 5.9 inches (150 mm) | Material: Plastic | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| halloween costume making supplie | Material | Quantity | Weight | Colors |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CALPALMY 14-Pack Paper Mache M | Paper mache | 14 masks | — | — |
| Dxhycc White Marabou Feather B | Natural turkey feathers | — | 20 g | — |
| Jashem 8 Pairs of 22mm Realist | Acrylic and plastic | 16 pieces (8 pairs) | 0.01 kg | Blue, gray, green, and brown |
| Large Self-Adhesive Googly Eye | Plastic | — | — | Black and white |
More Details on Our Top Picks
CALPALMY 14-Pack Paper Mache Masks, 2 Sizes
For a Halloween craft table where several people are making characters, CALPALMY’s blank mask set is the clearest all-around starting point. It includes 14 paper mache masks, split evenly between small and large sizes, and elastic fasteners make each piece wearable as a base. That gives a group room to make matching designs or entirely different faces without sourcing a separate mask for every person. The two sizes also make this more adaptable than buying a single prepared accessory, though fit still depends on the wearer and the project.
The main tradeoff is built into the product: these are blank masks, not finished costumes. A maker needs to decorate them with paint, markers, fabric, or other materials to get a character-specific result. Compared with the Dxhycc boa, this set asks for more preparation but provides a more substantial costume foundation. Compared with either eye set, it offers a broader canvas rather than one focal detail. Its paper mache construction and non-toxic, biodegradable, recyclable material description may appeal for supervised craft activities, but the masks still call for age-appropriate tools and adult oversight when needed.
I’d choose this first when the costume plan involves face designs, a family activity, or a classroom group. Someone seeking a finished, dramatic accent with minimal crafting should look at the boa instead. And if the costume is already built and only needs a convincing creature eye, the Jashem set is more targeted. The CALPALMY kit earns the top spot because it supports the widest range of Halloween mask ideas and includes enough pieces to make the project collaborative.
Pros:- 14 blank masks support group projects and multiple costume concepts.
- Seven small and seven large masks offer more sizing flexibility than a single-size set.
- Elastic fasteners make the masks wearable as a decorated base.
- Paper mache is described as non-toxic, biodegradable, and recyclable.
Cons:- The blank surfaces need decorating before they look like finished costume pieces.
- The set’s two stated sizes may not fit every wearer or face shape.
- Paper mache is less suited to builds that need a rigid, weather-resistant mask.
Best for: Families, teachers, and makers preparing several customized Halloween masks in one session.
Not ideal for: Anyone who wants a ready-to-wear finished mask or a quick accent without painting and decorating.
- Quantity:14 masks
- Size mix:7 small and 7 large
- Small dimensions:6.8 × 8 inches
- Large dimensions:7.5 × 9.5 inches
- Material:Paper mache
- Fastening:Elastic fasteners
- Age range:6 years and above
- Material claims:Non-toxic, biodegradable, and recyclable
Our verdict“I rank this first for Halloween costume making because it gives groups a versatile wearable base, provided they are ready to decorate it.”
Dxhycc White Marabou Feather Boa, 2 Yards, 20 g
When a costume needs movement and texture rather than a new structure, the Dxhycc white marabou boa is the most adaptable accent in this lineup. At about 6.56 feet long and two to three inches wide, it can be arranged around a collar, hem, hat, or prop. Natural turkey feathers give it a soft, lightweight look that contrasts with the paper mache masks, which are rigid blanks meant to be decorated. The boa is also less character-specific than either eye option, so it can fit theatrical, whimsical, or holiday-inspired designs.
That flexibility comes with some handling. The boa may arrive compressed, and the product description recommends fluffing it with a hair dryer. Some feather shedding is normal, so it may not suit a project where loose fibers would be a problem or where the trim needs to stay pristine through rough handling. Compared with CALPALMY’s masks, it takes less design work to become a visible costume detail, but it does not create a wearable face or provide a stable foundation. Compared with the large googly eyes, it creates a broader, softer visual effect rather than a single bold focal point.
I’d pick this for feathered collars, angelic or theatrical looks, and costumes that benefit from a light decorative border. I would skip it for builds that need clean edges, heavy-duty trim, or a no-shed material. Its white color is useful when it matches the palette, but costume-makers who need a different color will have to plan around that limitation. It places second because it is easy to repurpose across costume details, while still requiring more care than a simple adhesive decoration.
Pros:- Lightweight natural feathers add soft texture and movement.
- The 2-yard length can be shaped around several costume parts.
- Useful across costumes, performances, crafts, and decorations.
- White works as a visible accent on many darker Halloween designs.
Cons:- It may arrive compressed and need fluffing with a hair dryer.
- Some feather shedding is normal.
- A single white color limits palette choices.
Best for: Makers adding soft feather trim to collars, hats, hems, props, and performance costumes.
Not ideal for: Costume-makers who need durable, non-shedding trim or a colored accent that matches a specific palette.
- Material:Natural turkey feathers
- Color:White
- Length:2 m (6.56 ft)
- Width:2–3 inches
- Weight:20 g
- Item weight:0.634 ounces
- Model number:623120
Our verdict“I recommend this boa for makers who want a flexible, flowing costume accent and can accept a little prep and feather shedding.”
Jashem 8 Pairs of 22mm Realistic Acrylic Eyeballs (Blue, Gray, Green, Brown)
Jashem’s acrylic eyeballs are the specialist choice for makers building a creature mask, doll, or Halloween prop that needs a more lifelike gaze. The set provides 16 pieces in four colors, with a three-dimensional design and centered pupils. At 22 mm, they read as small details rather than oversized comic features. Their concave backs are intended to help with glue or stitching, giving the maker more options than the self-adhesive googly eyes, whose backing is meant for smooth surfaces.
The distinction is visual as well as practical. These acrylic pieces are better suited to a monster, doll, or prop where a convincing eye matters; the 5.9-inch googly eyes are far larger and deliberately playful. The CALPALMY masks can serve as a base for either type, but the Jashem set requires a design that actually calls for multiple small eyes. It is not a general substitute for broad decorative trim, and the separate pieces mean placement and attachment work are part of the build.
One detail deserves care: the supplied product information contains a size discrepancy, with the title referring to 20 mm while the specifications state 22 mm. I use the 22 mm specification here, but makers working to a tight measured opening should verify the actual dimensions before cutting or finishing a prop. The listing also says it is not suitable for children under three. I place it behind the boa because it serves fewer costume styles, though it is the better match when realism and attachment flexibility matter more than speed or scale.
Pros:- Three-dimensional acrylic design gives props a more lifelike appearance.
- Sixteen pieces include blue, gray, green, and brown options.
- Concave backs are intended for glue or stitching attachment.
- Small scale suits detailed masks, dolls, and Halloween props.
Cons:- The listing has a size discrepancy: title says 20 mm while specifications say 22 mm.
- Attachment requires glue or stitching rather than a stated self-adhesive backing.
- Small pieces are not suitable for children under three.
Best for: Prop builders and costume-makers adding small, realistic eyes to masks, dolls, or creature details.
Not ideal for: Anyone who wants oversized cartoon eyes, a ready-to-attach decoration, or exact dimensions without confirming the size.
- Quantity:16 pieces (8 pairs)
- Specified size:22 mm (0.87 inch); title also mentions 20 mm
- Colors:Blue, gray, green, and brown
- Material:Acrylic and plastic
- Design:Three-dimensional with centered pupils
- Back:Concave, intended for glue or stitching
- Weight:0.01 kg
- Age note:Not suitable for children under 3
Our verdict“I’d choose this set for realistic small prop eyes when color choice and glue-or-stitch attachment matter more than quick application.”
Large Self-Adhesive Googly Eyes, 5.9 Inches, 2-Pack
If the goal is a deliberately silly monster, robot, or cartoon-like costume, these 5.9-inch googly eyes create a focal point that the other products cannot match. The movable black pupils add motion, while the self-adhesive backing is designed to attach to smooth surfaces without separate glue. That makes them faster to apply than the Jashem acrylic eyes, which are smaller and intended for glue or stitching. Their scale also means one pair can define a costume concept instead of acting as a subtle finishing detail.
The same scale narrows the use case. The pack contains only two eyes, so it is a single pair for a costume or decoration, not a multi-project eye assortment like Jashem’s 16 pieces. The adhesive is intended for smooth surfaces, which may rule out textured fabric, fuzzy materials, or curved builds unless the maker adds another attachment method. Compared with CALPALMY’s masks, these are an accent rather than a blank face base; compared with the feather boa, they bring a comic, high-contrast effect instead of soft texture.
I’d use them on a smooth mask, a costume prop, or a large decorative surface where the oversized scale is part of the joke. I would not choose them for realistic creatures, discreet details, or surfaces that the backing may not grip. They rank fourth because the effect is distinctive but highly specific: they solve the problem of making a costume visibly playful, not the broader task of creating a costume foundation or adaptable trim.
Pros:- Large 5.9-inch diameter makes the eyes an obvious focal point.
- Movable pupils add a playful effect.
- Self-adhesive backing avoids separate glue on suitable smooth surfaces.
- Useful for costumes, decorations, and classroom projects.
Cons:- The package contains only one pair.
- Adhesive is intended for smooth surfaces.
- The oversized cartoon look does not suit realistic or subtle designs.
Best for: Makers creating a cartoonish monster, oversized character, or bold prop on a smooth surface.
Not ideal for: Costume-makers needing realistic small eyes, multiple pairs, or reliable adhesion to textured materials.
- Pack quantity:2 eyes
- Diameter:5.9 inches (150 mm)
- Material:Plastic
- Colors:Black and white
- Pupils:Movable black pupils
- Adhesive:Self-adhesive backing
- Intended surface:Smooth surfaces
- Uses:Costumes, crafts, decorations, and classroom projects
Our verdict“I recommend this pair when oversized, movable eyes are the main costume effect and the attachment surface is smooth.”
How We Picked
I compared these four supplies by their role in making a Halloween costume, rather than treating them as interchangeable craft decorations. I gave priority to items that provide a useful costume starting point, support more than one project, or add a distinct visual effect. That puts the 14 blank masks first: they give a group a wearable base and invite customization. The feather boa follows as a flexible trim material, while the two eye products rank lower because they serve narrower design needs.
I also considered the amount of finishing work each item asks of the buyer. The masks are intentionally blank, so they need paint or other decoration before they look like a finished character. The boa may need fluffing after unpacking and can shed. The oversized googly eyes have a self-adhesive backing, but it is meant for smooth surfaces. The realistic acrylic eyes offer a concave back intended for glue or stitching, which gives more attachment options but requires the maker to plan the construction. These differences matter more than a feature list alone: a costume-maker short on time may prefer trim that can be attached directly, while a family or classroom can get more use from a blank base that each person can personalize.
Finally, I weighed quantity, size, and design flexibility against likely Halloween uses. A pack of small prop eyes may stretch across projects, but it cannot replace a large playful pair. Likewise, a long feather accent can work across a costume, party outfit, or decoration, yet it does not supply a mask structure. My order favors broad costume utility first and specialty effects after that. I describe the tradeoffs alongside each choice so readers can match the item to the build they have in mind.
| halloween costume making supplie | Material | Colors |
|---|---|---|
| CALPALMY 14-Pack Paper Mache M | Paper mache | — |
| Dxhycc White Marabou Feather B | Natural turkey feathers | — |
| Jashem 8 Pairs of 22mm Realist | Acrylic and plastic | Blue, gray, green, and brown |
| Large Self-Adhesive Googly Eye | Plastic | Black and white |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Halloween Costume Making Supplies
I’d choose Halloween costume supplies by starting with the part of the costume that still needs solving: its base, its texture, or its defining detail. The four products here occupy different points in that process, so the right choice depends on how much of the build is already complete.
Start with the costume’s construction stage
If you have not settled the face design or are making costumes with several people, begin with the CALPALMY masks. Their blank surfaces leave room for separate character designs, and the 14-piece count supports a group activity. This also means the masks require additional decoration. If the costume already has a face structure, adding another mask base may be unnecessary; in that case, the boa or eye pieces can add a more focused finish.
For costumes without a mask, the Dxhycc boa can supply visible texture around an edge or accessory. The two eye options make sense later in the build, once you know the character calls for eyes at a particular scale. Buying a specialty detail before choosing the costume’s overall look can leave you with an effect that does not fit.
Match the visual effect to the character
Feathers suggest softness, movement, and theatrical trim. The white boa is a natural match for a costume that needs a light border or a feathered accent. Jashem’s acrylic eyes lean toward realism and detail, with several subdued color choices for creature masks and props. The oversized googly eyes are the opposite: they are meant to look comic and conspicuous. Decide whether the design should feel soft, lifelike, or silly before choosing among them.
The blank masks do not dictate a style. Their advantage is that paint and other craft materials can take them in many directions. Their disadvantage is that the final effect depends on the maker’s design and finish, while the eye products arrive with a much more specific look already built in.
Check attachment and surface compatibility
Attachment can determine whether a supply works with a costume. The large googly eyes have self-adhesive backing for smooth surfaces, so they are a more direct option on a suitable prop or mask. Textured cloth and uneven surfaces may need another attachment approach. Jashem’s concave-backed eyes are intended for glue or stitching, which gives a maker more control but asks for extra assembly work.
The mask set includes elastic fasteners, while the boa description does not specify a fastener. Plan how to secure the feather trim to the garment or accessory. A comfortable wearable build also needs the added pieces positioned so they do not obstruct vision or interfere with movement.
Think about quantity and scale
Fourteen masks support a group project, and Jashem supplies 16 small eye pieces across four colors. The boa offers about 6.56 feet of material that can be divided or arranged across a costume. The googly-eye pair, by contrast, supplies just two pieces, but each is 5.9 inches across. That pair can dominate a design despite the low piece count.
For a single focal-point costume, large eyes may be enough. For a classroom or several masks, the mask set or smaller acrylic pieces provide more pieces to distribute. Consider both the number of costumes and the visual scale you want; a lot of tiny details cannot replace one oversized centerpiece, and a giant eye may overwhelm a small mask.
Account for finishing work and handling
The products ask for different kinds of preparation. The masks need decoration, the boa may need fluffing after unpacking and can shed, the acrylic eyes need an attachment plan, and the oversized googly eyes need a compatible smooth surface. These are manageable tradeoffs, but they affect the time and materials a project requires.
If you want the most open-ended project, choose the blank masks and plan a decorating session. If you want a soft accent and can accommodate some feather handling, choose the boa. For eyes, favor Jashem when attachment flexibility and a realistic look matter, and choose the oversized self-adhesive pair when the surface is smooth and the comic scale is intentional.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which supply is the best starting point for a group Halloween costume project?
I’d begin with the CALPALMY mask set for a group project. It includes 14 wearable blank masks in two sizes, giving participants a shared base while leaving each person free to create a different character. Plan time and materials for decorating because the masks do not arrive with finished designs.
Which product works best when I want a realistic eye detail?
Jashem’s acrylic eyeballs are the closer fit for realistic small details. They come in four colors and have concave backs intended for glue or stitching. The listing has a size discrepancy: its title mentions 20 mm while its specifications state 22 mm, so I’d check the dimensions before designing a precisely sized opening.
Can the large googly eyes attach to fabric costumes?
The backing is described for smooth surfaces, so I would not count on it gripping textured fabric or fuzzy materials securely. They may work directly on a smooth mask or prop. For a different surface, plan another attachment method and check that it holds before wearing the costume.
Does the feather boa need preparation before use?
It may arrive compressed, and the product description recommends fluffing it with a hair dryer. Some feather shedding is normal, so I’d give it a little preparation time and attach it where loose feathers will not interfere with costume comfort or nearby surfaces.
How should I choose between the two eye products?
Choose Jashem’s 22 mm specified acrylic eyes for small, more lifelike prop details and glue-or-stitch attachment. Choose the 5.9-inch googly eyes for an intentionally oversized, playful effect on a smooth surface. Their scale and attachment styles are so different that the character design should decide between them.
Conclusion
For a family, teacher, or group making several face designs, I recommend CALPALMY’s 14 blank masks because they provide the most flexible costume starting point. If your outfit needs movement and a soft border, the Dxhycc feather boa is the better match, as long as you can handle some fluffing and shedding. For realistic creature props, choose Jashem’s acrylic eyes and account for the stated size discrepancy; for a comic oversized character on a smooth surface, the large googly-eye pair makes the clearest statement. Each pick serves a different stage of costume making, so I’d let the unfinished part of your design determine which one belongs in your craft kit.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
